They answer different questions, so their results are not meant to match. The Material Simulator compares raw materials per kg, counting only raw material extraction. The LCA calculates the impact of the materials and articles you declared, from the data you provided.
| Material Simulator | LCA of a material | LCA of an article | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | Which raw-material composition has a lower impact? | What is the impact of a material I have declared? | What is the impact of an article I have declared? |
| Scope | Raw material extraction only; no processing (leather is the exception: it includes tanning) | The material as you declared it, including its Processing, Finishing and Transport | The article’s life cycle, by phase: Extraction, Processing, Finishing, Manufacturing, Transport, Packaging |
| Unit | Per kg of raw material | Per kg of material (as shown in LCA > Materials) | Per unit of article (as shown in LCA > Articles) |
| Input | The Base and Alternative compositions you select | Your declared data: composition, origins, processes and losses | Your declared data: weight, materials, losses, suppliers, origins, packaging |
| Effect on your data | None | Results of your materials | Results of your articles |
Why the numbers differ
- Different scope. The LCA of a material includes the processing steps declared for it, and the LCA of an article includes all the phases of the article’s life cycle. The simulator covers raw material extraction only, except for leather, which already includes tanning.
- Different unit. The LCA of an article is per article, so it can’t be compared directly with a per-kg result. The LCA of a material is also per kg, but its result still differs because of the scope above.
- Different data. The LCA uses your declared supply chain. The Material Simulator uses only the composition.
Does a simulation change my results?
No. A Material Simulator scenario doesn’t recalculate or modify any material or article in your projects.
Which one to use
- To choose between materials: Material Simulator.
- To know the impact of a material or an article you have declared: LCA.
- To estimate the impact of a full product before production: Impact Simulator.